The Media and Gender-Based Murders of Women: notes on the cases in Europe and Latin America

The Media and Gender-Based Murders of Women: notes on the cases in Europe and Latin America
of 14
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
   1 The Media and Gender-Based Murders of Women: notes on the cases in Europe and Latin America 1   Patsilí Toledo and Claudia Lagos 2   Introduction Violence against women, especially its most severe form, femicide/feminicide, is caused by many factors, suc as social constructs and te symbolic violence of wat it means to be a man or a women in different societies! "n contemporary societies, mass media plays a fundamental role in tese constructs due bot to te content, language and narrative used, and to audience consumption! Tis article analyses te connections between gender#based murders of women and te media coverage of tese murders, particularly in $urope and Latin %merica! &at effect, if any, does te broadcasting and coverage of murders of women ave on te victims and perpetrators, and on society as a wole' &at role can or sould (ournalism and te media play in violence against women' "s regulation necessary and/or legitimate' )   I. Female homicide and ender-!ased "iolence *omicide is a serious crime everywere! "t violates an individual+s rigt to life and as terrible conseuences for society as a wole, in te form of te suffering wic te loss of a loved one causes and te feelings of public insecurity tat omicide provo-es, wic in turn erode social and uman capital and undermine community development .anpat et al, 2011 10! Te 3nited 4ations 5ffice on 6rugs and Crime .3456C, 2011 confirmed tat tere as been a decrease in omicides at global level in te last few decades, but tis decrease does not apply to female omicides! &ile tey still represent a minority of total omicides, women are te main victims of domestic or intimate partner violence, crimes wic are not decreasing over time 7 ! 4early 708 of women murdered all over te world ave died at te ands of teir intimate partners .&*5, 201)! 6espite te 1  Tis article was commissioned by te *einric 9:ll ;oundation! Te autors tan- te foundation for its support, as well as (ournalist <icardo <amíre= for is support in te literature review! 2  Patsilí Toledo as a P6 in Constitutional Law from te %utonomous 3niversity of 9arcelona! Claudia Lagos as a >aster in ender ?tudies from te 3niversity of Cile! )  To tis end, articles publised over te last five years in specialist (ournals on communication, (ournalism studies and gender studies were reviewed! <elevant manuals produced by te industry, professional associations and oter bodies related to te prevention of violence against women and uman rigts in general, bot globally and locally, were also ta-en into consideration! ;urtermore, it sould be pointed out tat te cases mentioned are not e@austive and tey are used to illustrate te ob(ectives of tis article as opposed to giving a complete report of tis problem! >edia representations in fiction and entertainment programmes ave not been considered in tis article! 4everteless, teir social significance does need to be addressed, particularly fiction programmes .series and soaps and entertainment .e!g! reality sows wic are very important due to te audience consumption and appropriation/resignification! ;uture papers sould investigate teir significance! 7  AB"n conte@ts of decreasing overall omicide levels, te sare of men among all omicide victims gradually decreases over time, wile te sare of female victims goes upD .3456C, 2011 EF!   2 significance of te penomenon, in many countries information on te relationsip between te perpetrator and victim is not recorded, or is only partially recorded .&*5, 201)! ;emale omicides ave gained more social and media attention in recent decades! ;rom te reporting of cases of disappearance, se@ual violence and murders of women in Ciudad GuHre=, >e@ico, te use of te e@pression feminicide or femicide as been e@tended in Latin %merica to refer to gender#based omicides of women, including cases were women are -illed by teir partners or former partners! Tese cases, called intimate femicides, ma-e up te ma(ority of female omicides at global level, as indicated by te 3456C! $urope too, as started to pay more attention to femicides, particularly tose committed by partners or former partners, under a variety of official terms feminicide/femicide, domestic violence, mortal victims of gender#based violence, and male violence against women, among oters! %ltoug in te ma(ority of countries tere are no regular statistics in tis respect, in countries were tey ave been evaluated, e!g! in ermany, it as been found tat alf of te women murdered were -illed by teir partners or former partners E ! "n ;rance, te number of women murdered due to Adomestic violenceD increased by more tan 208 between 2001 and 2012 I  and in "taly, te feminist organisations tat record tese deats ave reported a sustained increase in te murders of women in recent years J ! "n ?pain, tere as been an official record of mortal victims of gender#based violence K  since 200) F ! Tese records confirm tat intimate femicide is usually te corollary of previous violence by partners or former partners against women, i!e! tey are not isolated violent incidents! Tis underlines te role tat policies regarding gender#based violence in intimate relationsips may ave in preventing femicide and protecting women! "n Latin %merica, women+s organisations from various countries started to record tese cases over a decade ago, and in recent years limited official statistics ave also been available! &ile te real situation in te continent is eterogeneous, several countries present alarming rates of femicide/feminicide 10 ! "n general, te number of gender#based female omicides in Latin %merica E  %ccording to figures from te ;ederal Criminal Police 5ffice .9% for 2011 of )1) women murdered, 1E7 died at te ands of teir partner or former partner! Te report for 2011 .publised in 2012 is te first in wic te 9% as provided information on te relationsip between victim and murderer in omicides! I  <ising from 122 women -illed troug domestic violence in 2011 to 17K in 2012, according to figures from te >inistry of te "nterior publised in Gune 201)! J  <ising from K7 cases in 200E to120 in 2011, according to cases reported by te press! K  "n ?pain, Agender#based violenceD is considered to be violence Ae@ercised against women by teir present or former spouses or by men wit wom tey maintain or ave maintained analogous affective relations, wit or witout coabitation, as an e@pression of discrimination, te situation of ineuality and te power relations prevailing between te se@esD .%rt! 1 of 5rganic Law 1/2007, 2K 6ecember, on Compreensive Protection >easures against ender#based Violence! F  ?tatistical information on gender#based violence! ?ummary of mortal victims! %nnual data! >inistry of *ealt, ?ocial ?ervices and $uality, overnment of ?pain! %vailable at ttp//www!msssi!gob!es/ssi/violenciaGanuary/portal$stadistico/fica<esumen/ome!tm .%ccessed on 1K Ganuary 2017! 10  ;or e@ample, te rates of female omicide in several countries in Central %merica .suc as $l ?alvador and uatemala and some regions of >e@ico are around 10 per 100,000 women! "n contrast, tese rates in countries li-e Cile and %rgentina are lower tan 1!7 per 100,000 women!     ) were te perpetrators were te women+s partners is te tird igest worldwide, after ?outeast %sia and %frica .&*5, 201)! <egional differences can be e@plained by te differences in omicide patterns in general and according to te degree of cultural tolerance toward violence against women! II. The media and "iolence aainst #omen %s wen tal-ing about violence against women and te cultural conte@ts in wic it ta-es place, wen referring to te media, it sould be noted tat tere are also ma(or differences between te media systems in different countries and regions .*allin and >ancini, 2012 and 2007M &aisbord, 2000 11 ! Certain cultural matrices are particularly important to consider and are central to te sub(ect at and! 6ifferent television cultures can offer differing narratives and propose disparate visions of society! "n tis way, te narrativity of te news varies depending on te countries and teir cultures in some $uropean countries, tere is no room for te narrative tecniues of fiction .music, close#ups, reiteration, melodrama, wic are central to te narrative structure of te media in more sensationalist Latin %merica 12 ! Te role of te media in te production and reproduction of gender stereotypes, and particularly of gender#based violence, as been a source of concern in feminist studies for many decades .>attelart, 200)! Tis concern as given rise to researc into te place of women, and especially violence against tem, in areas suc as media production processes, gender representations in te media and debates and content in general in te media, among oters 1) ! &it regard to news production, we can note te low proportion of women wor-ing in editorial offices and in ig#level editorial positions ."&>;, 2010 17 ! ;urtermore, various studies demonstrate tat egemonic news values continue to correspond to a male#dominated culture wic permeates  (ournalistic routines in newsrooms .Tsui and Lee 2012M Neldes, ;ico and 6iddi, 2012M <oss and 11  Te main differences are given due to teir relationsips wit political systems .depending on ow closely tey are positioned to te political parties and te government, wit society+s intermediary organisations and wit commercial and mar-et mecanisms! 12  % ma(or precursor to popular mass culture sensationalism is te sensationalism of te religious imagery of te Catolic Curc, used as an instrument of propaganda .a dramatic/symbolic aestetic at a time wen te curc was losing its power in te Cristian world! Later on, te media of te popular mass culture .and particularly te newspapers would use te same resources to acieve te same effect appealing to primary instincts .fear, emotion, pain, suffering, (oy, etc! to try to cause sensation, i!e! to ma-e an impact .?un-el, 1FKE E0! 1)  ?ince 1FFE, te lobal >edia >onitoring Pro(ect .>>P as been investigating female presence and representation in te news in more tan one undred countries! Te results of te 2010 monitoring sowed tat tere as been a sustained increase in te presence of women in te media at global level, but it is nowere near being eual to mean .>>P, 2010! 17  %s as been documented in oter industries, te glass ceiling   penomenon can also be confirmed in te media! Tis concept as been used since te 1FK0s in studies in different countries, in all regions, to refer to invisible O but noneteless real # barriers tat women come up against in te wor-place!   7  Carter, 2011M Neldes and ;ico, 2010M Vega, 2010a and 2012, cited in C4TV, 201)! ;urtermore, different studies in various countries ave noted an over#representation of violence and discrimination against women and girls in news content 1E , especially news tat is broadcast on television .<ovetto, 201), on C4TV, 201) 2E! $ossi!le effects of ne#s co"erae of femicide%feminicide: a) Presenting violence against women as an individual or relationship problem: ;our frames ave been identified in te media coverage of femicide/feminicide and violence against women 1 a police frame or A(ust te factsDM 2 a frame indicating tat tese events appen to people wo are different to AusDM ) a frame tat blames te victims and/or e@cuses te perpetratorM 7 a frame tat implies soc- at ow AnormalD te perpetrator identified appears .illespie et al, 201)! Police frames or A(ust te factsD favour a sensationalist view, were gruesome details O suc as te number of times tat victim was stabbed # or oter specific details of te attac- are igligted! Tis frame is freuent in Latin %merica but it also e@ists in $urope 1I ! Te media often refers to  (ealousy 1J  or te use of drugs or alcool, uncritically (ustifying te actions of te perpetrator of te crime, or including e@pressions li-e Afrom love to murderD or Acrime of passionD, portraying te omicides as Alove storiesD 1K ! 1E  Tis is not to say tat te media gives more coverage to tese cases tan wat really occurs, but rater tat current news constructs e@acerbate certain cases and certain viewpoints, and, as a result, reinforce violence! 1I  Arenoble! 3n omme tue sa femme de neuf coups de couteauD B% man murders is wife by stabbing er nine times www!ouest#france!fr, 1E 4ovember 201)! %vailable at ttp//www!ouest#france!fr/grenoble#un#omme#tue#sa#femme#de#neuf#coups#de#couteau#1J1717I .%ccessed 1K Ganuary 201)! 1J  AVieu@#couple#au#lit 3n omme de K) ans tue sa femme de K0 ans par (alousieD B%n K)#year old man -ills K0#year old wife out of (ealousy, 6irect!cd, 10 4ovember 201)! %vailable at ttp//www!direct!cd/201)/11/10/un#omme#de#K)#ans#tue#sa#femme#de#K0#ans#par#(alousie!tml .accessed 1K Ganuary 2017! A%pre un falso profilo faceboo- il fidan=ato geloso la uccideD B5pens a false ;aceboo- account (ealous boyfriend -ills, at today!it, 2K 6ecember 201)! %vailable at ttp//www!today!it/cronaca/nun=io#proscia#omicidio#francesca#milano#gioia#del#colle!tml .accessed 1K Ganuary 2017! "n Cile, on 2I 4ovember 201), website www!emol!com ran te eadline A6etienen a su(eto acusado de violar y embara=ar a su i(astra en ?an <amnD B>an arrested for raping and impregnating is step#daugter in ?an <amn, wit te epigrap A$l ombre aprovecaba ue su pare(a iba a traba(ar para mantener relaciones se@uales con la adolescente, las ue abrían sido consentidasD BTe man waited for is partner to go out to wor- to ave se@ual relations wit te teenager, wic were consensual, wic was a contradiction considering tat tis situation constitutes rape in Cilean legislation! ?ortly after its publication, te site canged te epigrap, removing te last prase! %vailable at ttp//www!emol!com/noticias/nacional/201)/11/2I/I)1II2/detienen#a#su(eto#acusadob#de#violar#y#embara=ar#a#su#i(astra#en#san#ramon!tml .accessed 20 Ganuary 2017! %lso in Cile, on I 4ovember 201), Las Últimas Noticias  ran on te front page QLa triste confesin del marido de la ca(era perdidaQ BTe sad confession of te missing casier+s usband about te case of a cruel femicide! Te newspaper was accused by women+s organisations of advocating violence! %vailable at ttp//www!cooperativa!cl/noticias/pais/mu(er/observatorio#de#gGanuary#y#euidad#acusa#a#diario#de#apologia#a#la#violencia/201)#11#0J/101E2)!tml .accessed 20 Ganuary 2017! "n ?pain, in 4ovember 201), a television station illustrated wit a meat mincer te dismemberment of a woman, news tat was described as sensationalist, umiliating, offensive, morbid and distasteful by several organisations! %vailable at ttp//www!uffingtonpost!es/201)/11/1)/descuarti=amiento#mu(er#toledoRnR72I7KK7!tml .accessed 20 Ganuary 2017! 1K  A?ursis pour un mari ui a tuS sa femme malade d%l=eimerD B?uspended sentence for a man tat -illed is wife wo ad %l=eimer+s disease, Le Figaro , 20 Gune 2012! %vailable at ttp//www!lefigaro!fr/actualite#france/2012/0I/20/0101I#20120I20%<T;"00770#al=eimer#le#meurtre#d#un#mari#desespere!pp .accessed 20 Ganuary 2017!   E  Tese frames maintain a critical disconnection between femicides/feminicides, presented as isolated, individual cases, and domestic violence as a broader social problem .illespie et al, 201)! % recent study carried out in ?weden sows tat te ma(ority of news studied describes violence as te result of imbalances in te family system, placing te focus of te problem at individual level, wic prevents violence being considered a social problem .*alili, 201)! "n "taly, feminist organisations recently reported te inappropriate treatment in te press of femicide/feminicide cases, for instance, cases tat are described as family tragedies and not as violence against women, or tat indicate depression due to te loss of a (ob as a (ustification, or tat insist on interviewing neigbours only to sow tat te murderer was a good man 1F ! "n te 3nited ingdom, as a result of te Leveson investigation 20 , various women+s organisations presented information on news coverage of violence against women in 2012 described as eiter Aintrusive, inaccurate, wic misrepresented or wic were misogynistic, victim#blaming or condoning of V%&D, giving several e@amples 21 ! b) The copy-cat effect % particularly significant aspect in te field of mass communication researc is weter te media can affect individuals+ beaviour! Tere is evidence tat tis as occurred in cases of yout suicide .>almut and 9riere, 1FKI! Te copy-cat   effect is mentioned in various reports in relation to cases of women burned wit acid in countries li-e 9anglades, "ndia and Cambodia, were it is maintained tat te increase in cases of women burned in tis way may be due to te copycat effect .alantry and estenbaum, 2011 10! Te case of Cambodia is of special interest on E 6ecember 1FFF, singer Tat >arina was attac-ed wit acid and te case was igly publicised 22 ! 9efore tis case, te number of acid attac-s recorded was relatively low, but since ten tere as been a sarp increase in tese types of attac-s .alantry and estenbaum, 2011! 9etween 6ecember 1FFF and >ay 2000, tere were 1E attac-s, si@ of wic also too- place in 6ecember .L"C%6*5, 200) E! Te Tat >arina case stirred up great media attention as did te fact tat te alleged perpetrator and accomplices were not arrested or 1F  A"l ACorriere della ?eraD non conosce il femminicidio nS le sue causeD, publised in blog n altro genere di comunica!ione , 2 Ganuary 2017! %vailable at ttp//comunica=ionedigenere!wordpress!com/category/cronaca#2/femminicidio#cronaca/ .%ccessed 20 Ganuary 2017! 20  Te investigation of te *ouse of Lords, eaded by Lord Leveson, too- place after confirming tat (ournalists and ig e@ecutives ad been bugging te pones of victims of violent crimes and bribing police to Aget informationDD! Te investigation concluded wit te Leveson "nuiry into te Culture, Practices and $tics of te Press, publised in 4ovember 2012! 21  A$nd Violence %gainst &omen Coalition, ;inal ?ubmission to te Leveson "nuiryD, Ganuary 2012! %vailable at ttp//www!levesoninuiry!org!u-/wp#content/uploads/2012/01/$nd#Violence#%gainst#&omen#Coalition#?ubmission!pdf .%ccessed 1K Ganuary 2017! 22  A%cid#Laced VengeanceD, The "ambodia #aily $%%&%N# , E#I ;ebruary 2000! %vailable at ttp//www!camnet!com!-/cambodia!daily/selectedRfeatures/acidRlacedRvengeance!tm .%ccessed 1K Ganuary 2017!
Similar documents
View more...
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks

We need your sign to support Project to invent "SMART AND CONTROLLABLE REFLECTIVE BALLOONS" to cover the Sun and Save Our Earth.

More details...

Sign Now!

We are very appreciated for your Prompt Action!